1.888.BETTER5

All online orders must total at least $25. Please do not use our online store for orders over $100. If you wish to place an order over $100, please use our contact form, or call us at 610.926.4192 so we can make shipping arrangements.

Cookies

chocolate-chip

$5.25 Chocolate Chip Cookies

If you are a lover of buttery, crispy chocolate cookies, you have just found your treasure. These cookies will take you back to your grandmother’s kitchen.


chocolate-chocolate-chip

$5.25 Double Chocolate Chip

This chocolate cookie is buttery and loaded with everyone’s favorite chocolate chips. A well deserved treat!


snickerdoodle

$5.25 Snickerdoodle

For all of the cinnamon lovers out there, this one is for you! These cookies are made in small batches to ensure the homestyle taste. Our mother’s recipes have never disappointed!


oatmeal-raisin

$5.25 Oatmeal Raisin

Plenty of raisins with a great cookie crunch. These traditional oatmeal raisin cookies are packed with oats, raisins, and love.


butter-toffee

$5.25 Toffee Crisp

These are an instant favorite. Sweet toffee bits are mixed with a crunchy all butter cookie. It’s like a cookie and a candy bar combined! One is never enough!



Pies

shoofly

$7.95 Wet Bottom Shoofly Pie

A special blend of syrups make this wet bottom wonder a crowd pleaser. The flaky crust and sweet filling of this Pennsylvania Dutch tradition is a winner.


Apple Pie

$7.95 Apple Pie

Fresh apples from a local orchard are the main attraction in this winner. We pride ourselves in our simple recipe. No fillers in this one! Cinnamon crumb topping paired with our shortbread crust are to die for.


BB Pie

$7.95 Blueberry Pie

Thick blueberry filling in a shortbread crust with crunchy crumb topping. Why wait for dessert?


Cherry

$7.95 Cherry Pie

Our Dad’s favorite. Sweetened sour cherries doubled with our flaky pie crust and sweet crumb topping makes this a family favorite.


$7.95 Pumpkin

Our milk-based pumpkin custard is one of the best around. So firm, you could eat it out of your hand. No fork needed!



Cakes

$5.25 7oz Personal Sized Cakes

7 ounce personal sized cakes, all in individual re-sealable containers. Four fantastic flavors.



Cupcakes

Banana

7.95 Cream Cheese Filled Cupcakes

Re-sealable six packs of cream cheese filled cupcakes. Available in 7 flavors. Which will be your favorite?